Democracy is vulnerable

Many people take democracy for granted, but democracy is rather vulnerable. Several countries in the world are moving from democracy towards a more authoritarian and dictatorial rule. Are there other ways to achieve fair rule than democracy as we know it today?

Accessibility icon Democracy is vulnerable

Is democracy about to fall?

The political ruling in different countries has made many people disappointed with democracy. Because of economic crises, many leaders want to go back to autocracy, which means that the power belongs to one person or a small group. 

Not enough support

Support for democracy is at its lowest since World War II, especially in the Western world. This means that many citizens do not vote in elections. If it continues like this, only half of the people in the West will vote in five years’ time.

How will we be ruled?

What will happen if democracy disappears? What will replace it? Will it be dictators or perhaps artificial intelligence?

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 3

Neste avsnitt
En mann styrer mange mennesker med tråder.
En mann styrer mange mennesker med tråder.

Have we learned anything from history?

Have we learned anything from history? Most people want to live safely and be able to decide about their own lives. But why do so many people experience the exact opposite?

Different forms of government

Democracy has more often been the exception than the rule. Many countries have been ruled by dictators. Democracy and dictatorship are very different. 

Dictators and oligarchs

Dictators are people who rule a country by themselves. One example is Adolf Hitler in Germany during World War II. 

Oligarchs are a group of people who are in power. Oligarchs can rule a dictatorship. Many of the leaders are brutal and violent. 

Anarchy and meritocracy

In anarchy, no one has superior power. Society is ruled through cooperation and a wish for free will. Meritocracy is very rare. Here, those with special skills are put in charge. 

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 4

Neste avsnitt
En overdimensjonert rød mann ser ned på en stor folkemengde.
En overdimensjonert rød mann ser ned på en stor folkemengde.

Democracy in Athens

Democracy in Athens could look like a gentlemen’s club. Only 10 percent were allowed to vote. This was only men, not women or slaves. 

The men who were allowed to decide met a few times a month and cast their votes by putting colored stones in a jar.

There were no political parties or elections. There was nothing that controlled power. So those in charge could commit offenses without being punished for them.

Since there were so few people in the assembly, it was more like a direct system than a democracy like the one we have in Norway today. 

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 2

Neste avsnitt
En mann står i et tempel og snakker med en gruppe menn.
En mann står i et tempel og snakker med en gruppe menn.

The Corsican Constitution

Corsica is an island outside Italy. The democracy in Corsica is not that well known. The Corsicans attacked the other countries that had ruled. They created a constitution that all citizens signed. This was something completely new.

It was supposed to be a democracy, both men and women were allowed to vote. But the French invaded Corsica in 1769 and took away democracy.

📷  The port of Bonifacio in Corsica.
Forrige avsnitt

1 / 2

Neste avsnitt
Havneområde på Korsika med mange båter og en festning.
Havneområde på Korsika med mange båter og en festning.

Democracies began to flourish

Democracy started in the mid-19th century. Many people got an education and wanted to use their voices. The ruling power realized that they couldn’t keep the people out of politics. When many people vote, democracy grows.

📷  People going to vote in the US.

The democracies grow in three major waves:

  • The first wave came in the first half of the 19th century. That is when almost all white men in America got the right to vote.
  • The second wave came after World War II. In 1962 there were 36 democracies. 
  • The third wave was between 1970 and 1990. Because of the fall of the Soviet Union, many dictatorships fell in Europe and Latin America.

Democracy became very popular between the second and the third wave. People were optimistic because democracy was viewed as the only form of ruling a country. At the beginning of the 2000s, it was believed that democracy was here to stay.

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 3

Neste avsnitt
Mange mennesker på vei i samme retning.
Mange mennesker på vei i samme retning.

Many democracies disappeared

After each wave, democratic development slowed down. This led to some countries going back to authoritarian ruling. The most critical period was after the First World War. Between 1922 and 1944, the number of dictatorships grew, and the democracies became fewer.

📷   The Soviet Union was a dictatorship under the rules of Vladimir Lenin (1917-1924) and Josef Stalin (1924-1953). The picture shows the flag of the Soviet Union used between 1923-1991.
Sovjetunionens flagg
Sovjetunionens flagg

Internal resolution

Democratic institutions often disappeared in the past because of a military coup. The military took power and made all the decisions. Today there are not that many military coups, but taking over power can happen in other ways. This is called internal resolution.

On the outside, it may look like nothing has changed. The countries still have elections and political parties. But the takeover starts from the inside. One example of such a coup is how Adolf Hitler came to power in Germany in the 1930s.

Hitler gains power

Hitler tried to take over power in Germany through a coup. He didn’t make it. He created the Nazi Party so he could work from the inside instead. The Nazi Party became big and powerful. In 1928, it got 2 percent of the votes, but in 1932, it got 37 percent. Hitler understood that he had to win the votes of the people. They voted for Hitler because of the crises in the country, and they thought Hitler would save them from poverty.

The Reichstag fire

The Reichstag building is Germany’s parliament building. There was a fire here in February 1933. The fire helped Hitler to become Germany’s leader. Hitler was the leader before the fire, but after the fire, he banned all other parties and Hitler took control of Germany.

When the Nazis ruled, people no longer had the same civil rights. Those who were against Nazism were arrested or evicted. It only took a month before Hitler had complete dictatorial power. 

Take advantage of a country’s economic crisis

We have seen similar ways to gain power in countries like Turkey, Russia, Hungary, Venezuela and Nicaragua. The leaders have taken advantage of different crises in the country.

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 4

Neste avsnitt
Riksdagen i Berlin brenner 1933.
Riksdagen i Berlin brenner 1933.

The road to power

So how do these leaders gain power through the inside?

  • They can start by gaining power over the courts. Then they can choose who they want as a judges and in other positions. 
  • They can take control of the media. These must be forced to cooperate and be silent.
  • The last thing is to create problems for the enemies by changing the election rules.

When this process is underway, the country is on its way to becoming an autocracy.

Why do we choose such leaders?

Bad economy and high unemployment are often important factors, and many people don’t know what the future will bring. Many of them think that it will not get any better and that living conditions will be worse in the future. So they do not see any benefits of democracy. 

Populist leaders find simple solutions to the problems, and they try to show voters that the future will be better.

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 2

Neste avsnitt
Mann med dress trekker et sceneteppe med godt vær for å dekke over det dårlige været.
Mann med dress trekker et sceneteppe med godt vær for å dekke over det dårlige været.

Can we imagine other systems?

Can artificial intelligence and technology take over democracy?

In 1651, Thomas Hobbes presented an idea about an automated state where decisions are made on the basis of research.  

But can we trust the machines?

Technology has its flaws and cannot always be trusted. Mistakes happen, and this can lead to serious consequences. Can algorithms give you the right answer? Sometimes yes, but computers have no emotions or values. So algorithms cannot decide whether something is morally right or wrong.

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 2

Neste avsnitt
Robot står og tenker med med høyre hånd på haka og med vektskåler og en dommerhammer i bakgrunnen.
Robot står og tenker med med høyre hånd på haka og med vektskåler og en dommerhammer i bakgrunnen.

How can we achieve true democracy?

There are different ways to take part in a democracy. In Norway, you can vote both in local and parliamentary elections. We vote for the person or party we want to represent us. This is called representative democracy. We think that the politicians we have voted for will make decisions we agree to, but that doesn’t always happen.

Referendums

A referendum is an election where all people can vote on a specific matter – direct democracy. One example was in 1972 and 1994 when the people were asked to decide if Norway should join the EU.

Direct democracy

It is difficult to rule a society with direct democracy. Imagine if everyone would be a part of every decision. This would take a lot of time and effort for everyone. You need to learn everything about health services, taxes, and so on. 

In practice, the use of technology will make it possible for everyone to be a part of democracy in this way. But there are more challenges than benefits. 

A digital version of yourself

A digital avatar of yourself can be a solution. By using artificial intelligence, the avatar can learn attitudes and values – so that the decisions it makes for you are in line with what you think. In this way, you do not need to choose a politician to represent you.

Still, this has its problems. Technology has not come this far yet to make it good enough. Who will program this? Who will secure the system from hacking? What if someone takes over your avatar and makes decisions for you?

Forrige avsnitt

1 / 5

Neste avsnitt
Syv avatarer sitter på stoler i en ring og samtaler med hverandre.
Syv avatarer sitter på stoler i en ring og samtaler med hverandre.

Democracy as a form of government

Democracy is the best way to rule a country. Democracies have never been to war against each other. That is a good reason to keep democracy in the future. 

But people must take part in democracy for it to work. What are your suggestions for what we can do – as individuals and as a society?

Stortinget
Stortinget

Democracies in the world

In the graph you can see how different forms of government have been shared in the world from 1789 until 2021.

Liberal democracies: Well-functioning democracies where the people decide who will rule the country. Protection of the individual’s rights is strong. The courts are free. The term “liberal” here refers to the protection of the individual’s rights.

Elected democracies: Democracies where free and fair elections are held. But individuals do not have the same protection as in liberal democracies.

Elected autocracies: Citizens can participate in elections. But they do not have the freedom to organize and express themselves, which is necessary for political elections to be free and fair.

Closed autocracies: The citizens are not allowed to participate in any form of election of the country’s political leaders.

Sources:

  • Thorsen, Dag Einar: autokrati i Store norske leksikon på snl.no. Hentet 24. august 2022 fra https://snl.no/autokrati
  • Gursli-Berg, Gunhild: Leviathan i Store norske leksikon på snl.no. Hentet 24. august 2022 fra https://snl.no/Leviathan
  • Hovde, Kjell-Olav; Svensson, Palle; Thorsen, Dag Einar: demokrati i Store norske leksikon på snl.no. Hentet 24. august 2022 fra https://snl.no/demokrati
  • Holm-Hansen, Jørn; Berg, Ole T.: oligarki i Store norske leksikon på snl.no. Hentet 24. august 2022 fra https://snl.no/oligarki
Forrige avsnitt

1 / 3

Neste avsnitt

Media rights:

    1. Getty Images
    2. Getty Images
    3. Getty Images
    4. Getty Images
    5. Getty Images
    6. Getty Images
    7. Getty Images
    8. Getty Images
    9. Getty Images
    10. Getty Images
    11. Getty Images
    12. Getty Images
    13. OWID
Close Icon

Loading...